Mechanical seals ekk technologies eagle industry co. Describe difference between mechanical seal and gland packing seal and packing are integral and essential elements in a pump system, shaft, and several other mechanical engineering applications. Like packing, the mechanical seal faces must also be lubricated. This is why pump packing is the primary source of packing for fire pumps and other applications that cant risk catastrophic failure. Upgrade from pump packing to mechanical seals gallagher fluid. It is a ropelike material that packed around the shaft, stuffing the gap between the shaft and the pump housing.
The liquidyne has a predictable lifetime due to the condition monitoring function. The mechanical seal mechanical seals have the purpose of preventing leakage of a fluid liquid or gaseous through the clearance between a shaft and the fluid container. Mechanical seals vs gland packing mechanical engineering. Also referred to as gland packing, it is a braided, ropelike, and lubricated material packed around the shaft in rings, physically stuffing the gap. Sprinkler irrigation, fire fighting, water supply to high rise buildings. Packing has been used to seal rotating equipment for years. When considering gland packing vs mechanical seal solutions, mechanical seals are the best for minimizing sleeve damage. Mechanical seal vs gland packing linkedin slideshare. Vulcan seals offer an extensive range of 20 gland packing types with a vast variety of materials and constructions to suit a wide range of industry applications. In continuation with previous article it is a guide in the usage of gland packings. Mechanical seals vs gland packing mechanical engineering site. The amount of power required to drive a mechanical seal is very less compare the pump having gland packing.
Another method of forming this seal is to use gland packing. Mechanical seal vs gland packings loss of material a basic comparison with the leakage rate for the compression packings and mechanical seal yields the followings. However, it can be a very costly venture over time as they require more maintenance, and also allow more product loss than mechanical seals. In this article, we will see the difference between the mechanical seal and gland packing mechanical seals vs gland packing. On average the majority of gland packing consumes 6 times more power than a balanced mechanical seal. Describe difference between mechanical seal and gland packing seal and packing are integral and essential elements in a pump. Requires leakage or it will burn will seal with invisible leakage. Garlock packing is designed to give the user the greatest. The difference between single and double mechanical seals. Without a seal if no mechanical seal or gland packing is used, the liquid leaks through the clearance between the shaft and the machine body. Because mechanical shaft seal failures are the number one cause of pump downtime, we decided to dedicate this column to mechanical seal basics. The inboard, or primary seal keeps the product contained within the pump housing. D gland packing or mechanical seal multistage horizontal. Mechanical seals and gland packing are the toprated and mostpreferred sealing mechanisms.
What is the difference between mechanical seal and gland packing. Compression packing technical manual draco mechanical. Whereas mechanical seal failure can necessitate the shutdown of the pump. Sealing systems for pumpssealing systems for pumps part i. The rate of leakage is higher for gland packing than mechanical seals. A guide to gland packing, selection of gland packing. Even when leakage isnt visible, harmful vapors could be escaping. Gland packing is still commonly used in many applications, however increasingly users are adopting mechanical seals for the following reasons the friction of.
The biggest benefit of using mechanical seals is the drastic reduction in leakage. A mechanical seal is a device that helps join systems or mechanisms together by preventing leakage e. Cornell pump company manufactures closecoupled and frame mounted centrifugal pumps for the agriculture, food processing, industrial, refrigeration, municipal, rental oem, mining, and oil and gas. The liquidyne pump shaft seals are the alternative to gland packing and mechanical seals. While advanced sealing solutions for rotary applications, such as mechanical seals, emerged over time, compression remains an important industrial tool. With proper application and design however, the leakage is so minute that actual droplets of liquid are. Packing seals are removed and replaced much more often than mechanical seals, which causes considerable wear and tear to the pumps as they are disassembled and reassembled. Plan 11 is the default seal flush plan for all single. Although mechanical seals can be costlier than packing seals, they are a great investment that can save you the costs of constant packing seal repairs and replacements. Gland packings dimerpack 1120 applications packing is used for supply and pumping water, autoclaves. Reinforced, braided, graphite packing with a corrosion inhibitor.
What is the difference in using mechanical seal and gland. Usually, the power will increase with an increase in the number of packing rings. Mechanical packing and gasket catalog rotating equipment sealing application specific 1740. Mechanical seal is required where zero tolerance for leakage for fluid to be sealed. Whereas the gland packing is used where leakage of fluid is used for lubrication of gland as well as no hazard. Combine the overtightening of the front end of the gland with the oxide impregnated gland packing and we are. Mechanical seals reduce power consumption when compared to gland packing. Mechanical seal vs gland packing mechanical seals and gland packing are integral parts of all pumps and shafts and used in many engineering applications. The gland nut allows the packing material to be compressed to form a watertight seal and prevent water leaking up the shaft when the tap is turned on. By using mechanical seal the loss of product due to leakage in reduced more than 99. In fact, it is one of the oldest, if not the oldest, form of sealing a rotating shaft. Corrosion resistant alloy metal parts and bunan secondary sealing elements are.
Mechanical seals for pumps how mechanical seals work. Consider sealing with airan alternative to gland packing. Mechanical seals incorporate a seat stationary ring. This is one of the major parameters for selecting mechanical seal over the gland packing.
Seal basics a mechanical seal is a device used to seal the interface between a rotating shaft and a stationary housing figure 1. Single mechanical seal the single mechanical seal uses a simple face pair rotating face and static face to seal the hydraulic part from the atmosphere. Mechanical seal vs gland packings loss of material a basic. On the other hand, the mechanical seal having primary seal faces which are having very less frictional losses. The carbon yarn reinforcement is provided within the graphite tape yarn as well as the braided construction. Running rotating equipment with packing in the stuffing box is like driving your car with the hand brake on. Secondary seal nbrepdmviton spring and punched parts steel working conditions mediums.
A mechanical seal, and more specifically a double mechanical seal, should always be used when the pumped fluid presents a safety, health, or environmental hazard. Although mechanical seals had been around for many decades and now it. What is the difference between mechanical seal and gland. Gland packing is still commonly used in many applications, however increasingly users are adopting mechanical seals for the following reasons the friction of the shaft rotating wears away at the. The gland at the rotating shaft of a centrifugal pump. Egger pumps have a standardised sealing chamber for mechanical seals in accordance with din en. Mechanical seals is not a seal but rather a restricting device. Installation of the new proflo seals covered single spring seal. The difference between mechanical seal and gland packing.
The garlock compression packing facility is committed to supplying the highest quality engineered products to industry throughout the world. Multistage pumps kirloskar brothers limited a kirloskar group company. The outboard, or secondary seal prevents the flush. In certain applications, gland packing is preferred over mechanical seals, e. Prior to the mechanical seals, the compression packing like gland packing were used as the sealants though they are still being used in number of applications. Mechanical seals and gland packing are integral parts of all pumps and shafts and used in many engineering applications. Both types of seals are used commonly and it depends upon budget, requirements and personal choice. With a lower k value, the safety against thermal overload will increase, but the mechanical seal may also lift off more. Water, oil, and chemical mediums with weak corrosion.
On an average most gland packing uses 6 times more electrical energy than a wellbalanced mechanical seal. This presentation is made by mohamed elkeik on 17102016 email. Due to this mechanical seal will consume 80% power assuming mechanical seal with pumping ring less than the gland packing. Therefore, a company using mechanical seals and jcb seal kit can definitely achieve the environment target and reduce the cost of effluent disposal. Mechanical seal technology and selection eagleburgmann. Difference between mechanical seal and gland packing.
A balanced, radially split end face mechanical seal that has seal faces, gaskets, and setting devices unitized into two semicartridge components. However, packing is notorious for damaging shafts, yet it. A double mechanical seal consists of two seals arranged in a series. That reduction in leakage also has an effect on a number of other things as well. A seal piping plan is designed to improve the environment around the mechanical seal and therefore increase the performance and reliability of the seal. With a gland packing if the aim is solely to prevent leakage. The selection of appropriate packing, the cutting methods like straight and angular, the means to extract the old. Heres an example where a paper mill replaced packing with a mechanical seal to stop leakage. Sealing systems for pumps sealing systems for pumps. Collar and gland assemblies have builtin axial and radial.
777 1141 1403 1439 1454 1080 1006 864 227 358 1244 440 1140 263 6 1454 994 521 1316 1152 219 683 882 796 1252 155 616 886 296 43 1283